Latest revision |
Your text |
Line 1: |
Line 1: |
- | ==QA Meeting Agenda==
| + | '''QA Meeting Agenda''' |
| | | |
- | Please place the things you wish to discuss at the QA meeting on [[IRC]] below. | + | Please place the things you wish to discuss at the QA meeting on IRC below. |
| | | |
- | '''In the next meeting...''' | + | '''Meeting details''' |
- | * I want to discuss how to integrate Fennec as 3rd party app into bugs.maemo.org
| + | |
- | **Do we need ttis integration? Why bugzilla.mozilla.org is not enough?
| + | |
- | **What are alternatives?
| + | |
- | **There is already [https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=526798 an open bug for this issue]. Feel free to add your thoughts!
| + | |
- | *How to build a bridge between bugs.maemo.org and [http://maemo.org/packages/repository/qa/fremantle_extras-testing/ the package voting system]
| + | |
- | **As somebody fills bug reports normaly only if I found a bug during normal daily use it would be nice to have a link to the application packge to vote for.
| + | |
- | --[[User:jukey|jukey]] 19:18, 11 November 2009 (UTC)
| + | |
| | | |
- | ==Meeting details==
| + | ''* IRC: irc.freenode.org" |
| + | "* Channel: #maemo-meeting" |
| + | "* Time: Tuesday, November 10th, 14:30 UTC'' |
| | | |
- | * IRC: irc.freenode.org
| + | '''Agenda''' |
- | * Channel: #maemo-meeting
| + | |
- | * Time: Tuesday, November 10th, 14:30 UTC
| + | |
| | | |
- | ===Agenda===
| + | * QA is good. |
- | | + | * The criteria are a good start, but need tweaks (see thread) |
- | * QA is good. | + | * The packages UI needs some streamlining for testers. |
- | * The criteria are a good start, but need tweaks | + | * As a tester, a better reminder of the checklist when checking |
- | * The packages UI needs some streamlining for testers. | + | would be good. I also like the ease with which I can give feedback. |
- | * As a tester, a better reminder of the checklist when checking would be good. I also like the ease with which I can give feedback. | + | * As a developer, I don't *think* I want to be constrained with |
- | * As a developer, I don't *think* I want to be constrained with "release early, release often" when fixing bugs or introducing new small features. | + | "release early, release often" when fixing bugs or introducing new |
- | * We need a mechanism to preserve karma or reset it to zero.
| + | small features (i.e. karma resets to zero). |
- | * Discuss the possibility of PPAs or personal repositories.
| + | |
- | * specific bug report should always be required to block a package from entering Extras.
| + | |
- | * Developer's karma and tester's karma should be incorporated so that a "developer with high karma would be able to push packages through the process faster, and a high rolling tester would be able keep bugs open and classified as critical in case of disagreement."
| + | |
- | * Bugtracker field should be a blocker ? what about background packages ?
| + | |
- | * What to do with CLI apps ?
| + | |
- | * Allow people to vote multiple time.
| + | |
- | '''Actionable items'''
| + | |
- | | + | |
- | # We recommend lowering acceptable karma from 10 to 5.
| + | |
- | # Thumbs down requires a comment as well.
| + | |
- | # Testers should follow the checklist closely so it is clear what the testing criteria are.
| + | |
- | # Positive package karma gets preserved for bug fixes, cosmetic changes.
| + | |
- | # Allow people to cast more than one vote for a package.
| + | |
- | # App authors should be *prevented* from thumbing up own app and that a maintainer thumbing it down removes it from the QA list
| + | |
- | # PPAs are bad.
| + | |
- | # Without an application, libraries do not go through the QA process. tester logs in, reviews app metadata on web, installs via .install, tests and then votes ;-)
| + | |
- | | + | |
- | ===Wishlist===
| + | |
- | | + | |
- | # Approval interface available in Application Manager.
| + | |
- | # User clicks a series of checkboxes, the app gets promoted automatically.
| + | |
- | | + | |
- | [[Category:Community]]
| + | |
- | [[Category:Quality Assurance]]
| + | |