Talk:Maemo.org logo contest submissions

(→Proposals with "Maemo")
(Listing rejected submissions)
Line 9: Line 9:
::What about putting a disclaimer on the top i.e. ''Submissions not following the contest rules will be removed from this page'' and removing them? The logos themselves are still uploaded and etc, so no big harm. A "Maemo" logo will not win the contest in any way, so it's not like the author is losing something in practical terms. They better know asap that their entry hasn't been accepted.--[[User:qgil|qgil]] 03:09, 20 June 2008 (UTC)
::What about putting a disclaimer on the top i.e. ''Submissions not following the contest rules will be removed from this page'' and removing them? The logos themselves are still uploaded and etc, so no big harm. A "Maemo" logo will not win the contest in any way, so it's not like the author is losing something in practical terms. They better know asap that their entry hasn't been accepted.--[[User:qgil|qgil]] 03:09, 20 June 2008 (UTC)
::: The sooner we move them away, the more time they have to create a new, compliant logo. --[[User:xfade|xfade]] 07:01, 20 June 2008 (UTC)
::: The sooner we move them away, the more time they have to create a new, compliant logo. --[[User:xfade|xfade]] 07:01, 20 June 2008 (UTC)
 +
== Submissions discarded ==
 +
Because of having "Maemo" instead of "maemo.org".
 +
=== dzahariev ===
 +
<gallery widths="300px" perrow="3">
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_dzahariev_1.png|The main idea is that Open Source software is like honey and all other products that are produced inside bee hive from the united efforts of the bees. So the bees are developers and the Maemo is a result of their work. I am not so good in design, but I think that the idea have a potential.
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_dzahariev_2.png|This is an idea for the icon.
 +
</gallery>
 +
=== fredyrivera ===
 +
<gallery widths="300px" perrow="2">
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_fredyrivera_1.png|Maemo People Ico
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_fredyrivera_2.png|Maemo People
 +
</gallery>
 +
=== jobelium ===
 +
<gallery heights="150px" widths="400px" perrow="2">
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_1.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_2.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_3.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_4.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_5.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_9.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_13.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_20.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_25.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jobelium_26.png
 +
</gallery>
 +
=== asgari ===
 +
<gallery heights="200px" widths="180px" perrow="3">
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_asgari_1.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_asgari_2.png
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_asgari_3.png
 +
</gallery>
 +
=== GarethLWalt ===
 +
<gallery widths="500px" perrow="2">
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_garethlwalt_1.png|Modern branding. This logo is easily readable at the size of a quarter. However, this pure vector logo is easily scaled to an unlimited size.
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_garethlwalt_2.png|Custom typography. The lettering on this logo was created carefully on a grid. The color and outline are examples.
 +
</gallery>
 +
=== jussi ===
 +
 +
<gallery>
 +
Image:Maemo.org_logo_contest_jussi_-004-.png|I know this is a little above and beyond. I got a little carried away. These are ideas for implementation on the core maemo brand level, where colour can be used to signify the difference between the maemo os (green) and the maemo community (orange red). I suppose this is more up to Nokia. ;)
 +
</gallery>

Revision as of 19:04, 20 June 2008

Contents

Proposals with "Maemo"

Even if it's clear in the instructions that the logo needs to have the text "maemo.org" and only that, there are many proposals on "Maemo". What should we do with them? Take them out of the submissions page? It would be counterproductive that other designers see the proposals and think that despite the rule it is ok to send more "Maemo" proposals.--qgil 20:30, 19 June 2008 (UTC)

X-Fade and I were discussing this on #maemo earlier. We could:
  • Drop the non-compliant submissions onto a separate page.
  • Mark them as non-compliant with a template with lots of red borders and text.
  • Remove them outright and notify the submitter that the submission is non-compliant.
Not sure what the best solution is, but we do need to do something about it soon. —GeneralAntilles 20:42, 19 June 2008 (UTC)
What about putting a disclaimer on the top i.e. Submissions not following the contest rules will be removed from this page and removing them? The logos themselves are still uploaded and etc, so no big harm. A "Maemo" logo will not win the contest in any way, so it's not like the author is losing something in practical terms. They better know asap that their entry hasn't been accepted.--qgil 03:09, 20 June 2008 (UTC)
The sooner we move them away, the more time they have to create a new, compliant logo. --xfade 07:01, 20 June 2008 (UTC)

Submissions discarded

Because of having "Maemo" instead of "maemo.org".

dzahariev

The main idea is that Open Source software is like honey and all other products that are produced inside bee hive from the united efforts of the bees. So the bees are developers and the Maemo is a result of their work. I am not so good in design, but I think that the idea have a potential.

This is an idea for the icon.

fredyrivera

Maemo People Ico

Maemo People

jobelium

asgari

GarethLWalt

Modern branding. This logo is easily readable at the size of a quarter. However, this pure vector logo is easily scaled to an unlimited size.

Custom typography. The lettering on this logo was created carefully on a grid. The color and outline are examples.

jussi

I know this is a little above and beyond. I got a little carried away. These are ideas for implementation on the core maemo brand level, where colour can be used to signify the difference between the maemo os (green) and the maemo community (orange red). I suppose this is more up to Nokia. ;)

Retrieved from "https://wiki.maemo.org/Talk:Maemo.org_logo_contest_submissions"